If you look at President Obama’s 2013 budget (which failed to pass in both houses: 0-414 & 0-99) there is one thing in it that Democrats and at least a few Republicans appear to support: the Automatic IRA (or Auto IRA).
Like any piece of proposed legislation there are many iterations of the idea before it become law. So far, the Automatic IRA isn’t law, but this is the general idea:
- applies to small businesses (10+ employees) at least 2 years old
- would require the small business owner to start a company IRA plan
- would require the small business owner to automatically enroll employees in the IRA
- employees could opt out
If this sounds slightly familiar to you, it’s because we already have an automatic 401K law. This law, passed in 2006, allows companies to automatically enroll their employees in the company sponsored 401K.
The Automatic IRA would be different not only because it’s an IRA vs a 401K, but because it isn’t only about automating the contribution, it’s about requiring/creating something that isn’t there to begin with.
Companies that currently have no retirement plan in place (around half the U.S. workforce, by some reports) would be required to start offering one.
The automatic 401K enrollment had bipartisan support as well, but it hasn’t done so well in changing the retirement savings landscape. Some stats are showing more harm than good from the change.
At first glance, I think the Automatic IRA could have different, far more positive results. But, the we’re-smarter-than-you government intervention usually does come with unintended consequences, so who knows what would come of this.
One obvious consequence is that you are putting a burden on small business to research and implement IRA plans. This is nothing to scoff at. As a small business owner who implemented his own solo 401K retirement plan, I can attest to the cost of the process. Proponents argue that most legislation has involved credits to offset costs. Opponents ask “what’s there to offset the loss of liberty?”
Thankfully, anyone can already open up their own Automatic IRA. If your employer doesn’t offer a retirement plan, create your own for free at any of the discount online brokers. Talk to your employer about creating a direct deposit into the account each month, or implement a simple automatic withdrawal from your checking account.
I honestly hadn’t heard much about this proposal (which has apparently been on the table for at least 5 years) until I read an article from SmartMoney.com about the candidates’ affects on retirement.
What do you think of the Automatic IRA? Nanny-state overreach that will never pass into law, or good government policy that’s sure to help millions?