Reduce Your Homeowners Insurance Policy Premium By Several Hundred Dollars

Save Money on Homeowners Insurance

Homeowners insurance. You don’t need it until you need it.

I recently reduced my annual homeowners insurance premium from $1,430 to $856.00 by not escrowing and paying annually, renegotiating my policy, and most importantly, raising my deductible. Here’s what went down…

I’m a homeowners insurance newbie. Up until last month, I hadn’t had to deal with a regular homeowners insurance policy. We used to only own a townhome, which came with the option to get away with just a cheap condo-type policy (i.e. $350 per year).

But now that I’m a full-fledged full-size homeowner, I have a regular-ole-more-than-a-grand homeowners insurance policy.

We’ve been in the house over a year now. So why am I just now addressing it? Well, to be honest, last year, when we got the policy, we were in the middle of making the home purchase and the last thing I wanted to do was dig into the details of making a smart homeowners insurance purchase.

So, at the time we just rang up Geico (who we have our auto insurance through) and had them dial up a homeowners insurance policy through one of their partners, ASI Lloyds.

Even though we didn’t escrow with our lender, Quicken Loans, we had to show evidence of a homeowners insurance policy and pay it at the closing. I’m assuming we probably could have extracted this from the closing/financing, but I didn’t catch it.

Our First Homeowners Insurance Policy

The policy we ended up with cost us $1,430 and covered our “dwelling” for $275,000 and personal property for $192,000. Additionally, it had general liability coverage of $300,000 and a $1,000 deductible, among other minor things.

A year goes by and I don’t hear anything about my insurance. Turns out I missed a notice about my insurance expiration. So I called up Geico again and asked to reinstate my policy before something bad happened and/or my lender threw a fit for me being uninsured.

The Geico representative was kind enough to compare other company rates and talk me through my deductible options. The options were sounding good, especially when I brought my deductible up to 3%.

Be Sure to Compare Rates

While we were on the phone I found out that the State of Texas (Department of Insurance) provides a free website ( which shows you the average insurance rates for different companies in Texas. Pretty handy. If you’re in the hunt for new homeowners insurance I suggest you utilize your state’s tool.

You can also use Gabi to shop your home insurance policy. Start your free review now.

Gabi Price: Free Gabi shops for your car & home insurance - saving you $865 on average! No fees, no forms, no spam. START YOUR FREE REVIEW Gabi We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

The No-Escrow Difference

One important thing to note here is that because I don’t escrow my insurance and taxes (i.e. pay for them along with my mortgage) I have ultimate flexibility when it comes to which insurance company I work with, when I make my payments, and how much my deductible will be.

Okay, the flexibility in payments is really the only thing that’s a real advantage, but I’m a fan of keeping variable costs separate so that you don’t take them for granted. Had I not been paying my own homeowners insurance, I likely would have not re-checked rates and called to lower my deductible (challenge me on that my escrowing friends).

I guess a counter-argument could be made that I was late in paying my insurance because I’m not escrowing. But I prefer to have the control, and like I said, I think this plays a role in me getting a better deal on homeowners insurance.

The Deductible is the Biggest Way to Save

In my case, not being escrowed made a big difference in the fact that I was flexible with the amount of deductible I was willing to accept on the policy. Going to a 3% deductible means I’ll be roughly $4,500 worse off if a fire takes out my home or a tree falls on the roof than I would have been with the $1,000 deductible. I’m willing to accept this risk.

This move saves me over $500 annually. Seen another way, I can take on a total loss every nine years and still come out ahead.

My advice is to be flexible with any insurance policy with regard to the amount of deductible. But don’t just chase the bottom line on the payment. Look at the overall picture, and certainly, never take on a deductible that you don’t have saved up already.

Many states regulate deductibles, so don’t assume you can do 3% as I did.

My final word is that it’s important to get homeowners insurance rate quotes annually and pay in full, if possible. Paying in full means you’ll typically avoid any monthly service fees.

Even if you escrow and pay your insurance each month, stop down annually and make a call to get homeowners insurance quotes. Check rates with Liberty Mutual and also shop your insurance with Gabi.

Other Important Notes About Homeowners Insurance

  • Look for discounts like multiple policies or security systems.
  • As with anything, don’t focus solely on cost. Get adequate insurance coverage.
  • Your credit history affects your premiums. 
  • Did your home recently gain or lose value? You may not need as much insurance coverage.

What’s been your experience with trying to save money on homeowners insurance? Do you fuss over the annual cost? Do you turn a blind eye to it because it’s in your mortgage payment? Are you meticulous about checking rates each year? How do you save?

Want My Free 31-Step Money Guide*?

Subscribe for free. Get my guide *31 Days to Improve Your Financial Life, welcome series, and regular Five Things digest. Join 30,000+ other followers.

Powered by ConvertKit

About Philip Taylor, CPA

Philip Taylor, aka "PT", is a CPA, blogger, podcaster, husband, and father of three. PT is also the founder and CEO of the personal finance industry conference and trade show, FinCon.

He created Part-Time Money® back in 2007 to share his advice on money, hold himself accountable (while paying off over $75k in debt), and to meet others passionate about moving toward financial independence.


    Speak Your Mind


  1. Earlier this year I got quotes on homeowners insurance as our yearly cost  had gone up by like $3-400 within a 2 year time frame, with no real reason given. Our insurance had ballooned to over $1100 on a $220,000 house, and I knew we could be paying quite a bit less.  
    I searched around for essentially identical policies through an indiependent broker that ends up searching a bunch of companies for you.  They found me a rate that saved me like $500.  They also saved us a bit and got us a further discount by bundling and switching our auto insurance. So in the end we saved a ton of money . 
    My advice, don’t assume that you’ve got the best rate. You might be able to save hundreds!

  2. Good analysis Phil.  I have to admit that I haven’t thought about our homeowner’s insurance in the 25 years since we’ve been here.  We’ve been pleased with Allstate where we have this, our auto, and personal umbrella policies.  Thankfully we’ve never had to see how well our coverage would work.  After watching our agent jockey things around with the kids and our auto policy I’m pretty comfortable that we have competitive coverage.  Again hope we never need to find out.

  3. Our rates have been fairly reasonable as well. We have all of our coverage through USAA and their rates have been pretty competitive, and the service is second to none. We don’t pay ours annually as the savings is not really much to speak of. Normally, I’d find a way to pay semi-annually or annually to save the money, but I like the convenience of having it in our mortgage payment.

  4. Mine is like SenseofCents’, only around $750/year for a fairly low deductible. Of course, having a small, inexpensive house helps with that too…

  5. SenseofCents says

    Luckily our home insurance has always been pretty cheap. It’s a little less than $700 a year. I tried shopping around but weirdly everyone wanted around $1,000 or more!

  6. Money Life and More says

    Plantingourpennies I 1,000% agree that Florida is horrible. There are no traditional big name companies here and you have to do a ton of research to make sure you’ll likely get paid if there is a major disaster in Florida because of all of the mid-market companies. I have to get Citizen’s for windstorm on top of that and they keep changing their policies every year but we’re forced to be insured with them… I guess that is the price we pay for having a rental townhouse 3 blocks from the beach!

  7. Plantingourpennies says

    Homeowners insurance has been a major thorn in my side.  Florida has a really weird homeowners insurance market, especially if you have a house that was built after 2003.  There are a ton of hoops to jump through and we even had coverage dropped on our pool and pool cage for a year because it would have cost an additional $2K in premiums per year for an additional $10K (max payout) in coverage on the pool.  It’s crazy the number of people that don’t actually understand their policies and might be over (or more likely under)-insured because of how confusing the insurance market is here.