Are Property Managers Worth Their Fees?

Are Property Managers Worth Their Fees?
Ask yourself a few questions before deciding to hire a property manager.

Someone will have to manage your property whether you are an accidental landlord or you plan to become a residential real estate investor.

Who will find new tenants for you when yours move out? Who will handle complaints about leaky faucets in the middle of the night? Who will handle tenants who do not pay rent on time?

You, the homeowner, could handle all of these things yourself, of course. That is assuming that you live a reasonable distance from your rental property and actually want to take on the responsibility. But what if you live in another state? What if you don’t like dealing with the confrontation of a non-paying tenant?

What if you simply do not have the time, energy, or proclivity to want to handle all of these things? These are just some of the reasons why hiring a property manager might be a great choice for you and your residential rental properties.

Isn’t A Property Manager Expensive?

When a lot of my friends and family hear I’m a landlord and outsource the property manager role to a firm, I’m always asked about the cost. In the grand scheme of things, hiring a property manager is not too expensive when you compare the amount of everyday and monthly tasks they handle for the property owner.

Managing a property is not very hard in most cases, but it is often time-consuming, especially when you are in-between tenants and looking for a new one or when there is a property issue.

A property manager typically charges a flat fee of 10% of the rent you charge. So, for example, if you charge your tenant $1,200 per month in rent, then a property manager will typically charge you $120 per month for their services. They collect the rent, take out their fee, and pass along the remainder to you. This is also after paying any maintenance and repair costs. You’re left with a cash flow to pay your mortgage, insurance, property taxes, private mortgage insurance (PMI), homeowners association (HOA) dues, home warranties, or any other fees.

What Services Does A Property Manager Typically Perform?

There are many things a property manager typically does for a landlord as part of the monthly fee that they collect. While this is not an all-encompassing list, it does provide you with a good idea of what you can expect the typical property manager to do for the fees they charge the homeowners.

  • Find and screen new tenants
  • Advertise your home vacancy online and in print
  • Evict non-paying renters, if needed
  • Collect rent payments and deposits
  • Handle calls from potential and current tenants
  • Schedule routine and emergency maintenance
  • Coordinate with contractors and home warranty companies
  • Conduct monthly or quarterly inspections
  • Show the property to new renters
  • Discounts on landlord insurance plans

Property Managers Understand State And Local Law

Additionally, property mangers know and understand the specific local, state, and federal laws that govern being a landlord such as accepting renters, removing non-paying tenants, application denials, which references to check, and other aspects of renting.

The law covers a host of specific details that you may not know (or even want to know). It is hard to keep up with all of the rules and law changes. Hiring a property manager absolves you of responsibility and puts it on the property manger’s shoulders.

A Property Manager Knows The Lay Of The Land

My property manager’s company manages over 200 single-family residential homes in a three-county area. She has a wealth of history and knowledge about the residential real estate market in our area. She knows exactly which types of homes and locations that are renting well in every season. She is very familiar with all of this data because she has a large pool of properties to reference, and this is the only job she has every day, 9 to 5.

Not only does a property manager know the lay of the land in your specific town or neighborhood, but they most likely are real estate agents as well. If they are real estate agents, they also have access to the real estate multiple listing service (MLS), which provides realtors with a wealth of data about all homes that have sold and/or been rented in the area. The MLS database can provide comparable properties (comps) and can query the database specifically for one or more specific points of interest.

Do you have a home with an in-ground swimming pool, for instance? What are the monthly rental prices similar homes have commanded over the past year when compared to ones that do not have a pool? This is just one of the many examples a property manager can search for on the MLS database.

Is A Property Manager Worth The Fee?

Of course only you can truly answer if a property manager is worth their fee. You will have to consider your profit margin. Is the rent you are able to charge your tenants barely covering your mortgage, insurance, private mortgage insurance (PMI), taxes, homeowners association fees, maintenance, and the host of other costs of investing in residential rental real estate?

Like most things in personal finance, the answer is that it depends. What do you want to do with your property? How involved do you want to be–or can you be? For many landlords, it makes sense to hire someone who can manage your property for you. But often it is simply a profit calculation you have to make and live with.

Do you manage your own rental properties? Or, have you hired a property manager to do that for you? Which course of action would you recommend for a new landlord? Why?

Avail LogoApartments Dot Com LogoBuildium Logo
Rent Collection$2.50 ACH Fee (Tenant Paid)
3.5% Fee for Credit or Debit Card
Free ACH
2.75% Fee for Credit Card
$1.00 EFT Payments
2.95% Fee for Credit Card
Deposit Time3 Days4-5 Days ACH
3 Days Express
1-2 Days
Restrict Partial PaymentsYesEnd of LeaseYes
Multiple Deposit AccountsYesYesYes, for an Extra Fee
Auto Late FeesFixed or %FixedFixed
Background Check$30 ($22.50 if bundled)$29.00 + taxIncluded
Credit Check$30 ($22.50 if bundled)$29.00 + taxPart of Screening (Above)
Digital LeasePart of Paid PlansNoAvailable
Renter's InsuranceAvailableAvailableAvailable
Best ForNew LandlordsMulti-Unit LandlordsFull-Time Landlords
Free AccountFree AccountFree Trial

Similar Posts


  1. Avatar DenverEric says:

    This is something I have seriously thought about. I am planning on renting my condo when it is time to move out, and we may bring on someone to handle the property for us. On the other hand, it would be nice to keep the 10% and do it ourselves. It just comes down to what we think our time and the hassle is worth to hand over.

  2. Avatar barbfriedberg says:

    Hank, In my professional life, I’ve had several property managers and in every case, they have been a pain in the neck. YOu have to manage the property managers and spend a lot of time checking their work. That said, find a good one, and the 10% fee is well worth it.

  3. Avatar BudgetBlonde says:

    I definitely think this is a good option if you don’t live in the same city as your property.

  4. Avatar Plantingourpennies says:

    We don’t use property managers, choosing to do it ourselves instead.  Additionally we moonlight as (no charge) property managers for my in-laws when they are out of town as they have a duplex in the same neighborhood as ours.  
    In general, I think property managers often are NOT worth it.  We make way more money on the property DIY-ing everything than putting multiple layers of middle men in the process.  For example, if a toilet is running, the tenant calls us, and Mr PoP stops in on his way home from work and takes 10-20 minutes to fix it.  $10 for the part.  If we had a property manager, they’d call the property manager, who would call a handyman, who would charge $10 for the part and another $100 for a billable hour.  And we would have paid $150 per month to have the property manager on call.  *Ugh*  We’ll take the calls and do the work ourselves.  Way more worth it in the long run.

  5. Avatar krantcents1 says:

    I prefer to manage my own properties. When I owned apartment buildings, I had a resident manager and I did everything else. I had a company manage a condo in a ski area and did an okay job. A management company will never look after the property the same as an owner.

  6. Avatar ayoungpro says:

    Right now we have one rental property (a condo) and we don’t utilize a property manager. I think it is pretty easy to manage one property, especially when it is only 10 minutes from where you live. In the future, when we get more properties, i’m sure a property manager will be worth their weight in gold.

  7. Avatar Momat3isplenty says:

    We chose to use a property manager for our “accidental landlord” property.  We just didn’t want to deal with the day-to-day management.  They charged us 5% of the rent.  We were losing money on the property anyway, so it wasn’t a stretch to let them take their $125/mth cut.  We weren’t thrilled with them however, they were a bit lax in taking care of regular maintenance and we had to talk to them about it.  We sold the property in 2011, and are so glad to be rid of it and the property management company.  We’re just not cut out to be landlords at all!

  8. Avatar OneSmartDollar says:

    I chose not to use a property manager for our condo.  I have a friend in Chicago who owns a couple of buildings.  If I need help I can just pay him each time.  Its better than paying each month.

Comments are closed.