Credit Card Rewards – Are They Really Worth It?

Credit Card RewardsThese last few weeks I’ve been thinking a lot about our credit cards, and whether or not we should just close the rest of our credit accounts.

My philosophy is becoming more and more anti-debt, and the idea of going credit card free is appealing, albeit a bit scary.

It’s becoming less scary as we get closer to having a fully funded emergency fund.

Currently we have two open credit accounts, a cash rewards Mastercard and an American Express.

One reason I’ve kept the accounts open is because they have a cash back credit cards rewards program. Every time I spend a certain amount of money, I get cash back on my purchases.

Sounds like a pretty good deal right?

This past week Consumer Reports released a study where they found that about 85 percent of U.S. households participate in at least one rewards program. 85%! Sounds like a lot of people in America must agree that rewards programs are a good deal.

Consumer Beware

While on the surface rewards cards may seem like a great thing to take advantage of, when you scratch below the surface you may find that they aren’t quite as good a deal as you thought.

Consumer reports found that people who have rewards cards often end up spending more money than those with a regular card, and on top of that, they don’t always reap the benefits of having the card.

Rewards program terms are often confusing and restrictive, and the rewards credit cards often have higher interest rates than some others that are available. If you’re not paying your balance off every month, you’re already erasing any savings you’ve made by having the rewards card in the first place.

Other rewards cards may have good terms, but charge an annual fee. This makes it unlikely that the consumer will come out ahead if they don’t spend a large amount of money on their card.

Still other rewards cards may be generous with their rewards, but they have an annual cap or limit which means you can’t fully realize the benefit of having the card.

Another problem is that a good percentage of people who have rewards credit cards don’t even bother to use their rewards that they’ve earned. From CNNMoney:

More than 41 percent of reward cardholders either rarely or never even bother to use their rewards, said a 2006 survey by GMAC Mortgage and Harris Interactive.

That seems like an awfully large number of people who sign up to get rewards, but then never even bother to use them. What a waste! Could it be just another indicator that our culture just doesn’t value saving as much as it does spending?

Avoid the Pitfalls of Rewards Cards

To avoid the pitfalls and get the most back from your reward credit card, Consumer Reports offers these tips:

  • Consider where you shop. Get rewards cards that fit your lifestyle and shopping patterns. In other words, if you don’t travel very often, don’t sign up for a travel rewards card. You might be better off using one that gives you cash back for gas, groceries and home purchases.
  • Project your spending. Figure out how much you think you’ll spend in a given year, and then find out how much you’ll gain for every dollar you spend. Subtract any annual fees or penalties and find out if the card is worth your time. If not, move on and find another one.
  • Favor cash back. Points vs. Cash back. Consumer reports found that cash back credit cards tend to offer better rewards. On top of that the cards that give points, often the points end up going un-used. Get a cash-back card to optimize your returns.
  • Skip credit if you carry a balance. If you don’t pay your bills of in full, you may want to pass on the rewards cards altogether. Because rewards cards often have higher interest rates, you may end up paying much more in interest than you reap in rewards. I know my wife and I only use the credit card when we know we can pay it off within a week or two.
  • Do the math on do-good programs. Some people are tempted to get a rewards card so that they can have the rewards sent directly to a charity of their choice. When doing this make sure you look into how much is being given because you’ll often find you can give more to the charity if you just get a cash back card and send the money to the charity yourself.
  • Use airline miles fast. If you use a card that gives you free airline miles, make sure to use your points as soon as you can. Airlines will often change redemption rules, and sometimes you’ll even lose your points if you haven’t used them in time.
  • Avoid temptation. Don’t justify spending on your credit card just because you want to get that “reward” of a new Ipod or digital camera. You’ll usually find that you end up spending more than you would have in the first place – enough that you could have just gone out and bought your own reward.

Need more tips and strategies for using rewards card wisely? This video is full of great ideas:

Conclusion – Be Careful

When it comes down to it I think it is clear – if you already have credit card debt and you’re trying to find your way out, DON’T use your credit card. Period. Lock it up and throw away the key.

But if you are debt free and are able to pay off your card every month without any problem, go ahead and take advantage of the rewards programs. But be careful which one you choose. Find a reward credit card that fits your needs and spending patterns.

Also, be careful that you’re not getting caught in the “spend to earn” trap. Studies have shown that people will often spend more just because they’re getting rewards. Don’t be a sucker, buy only what you need and what you would have bought anyway.

Here’s a list of some of the best reward and cash back credit cards available today.


This article was written by my friend Pete from Bible Money Matters.

Want My Free 31-Step Money Guide*?

Subscribe for free. Get my guide *31 Days to Improve Your Financial Life, welcome series, and regular Five Things digest. Join 30,000+ other followers.

Powered by ConvertKit


  1. Can you use a rewards card to pay your mortgage or would that be considered a cash purchase? Has anyone tried this, this seems like for me the fastest way to gain the rewards and just pay it off every month.

  2. That 85% number seems quite high. I haven’t seen this CR study. Did it include the new rewards debit cards as well? Interesting that GMAC found 41% don’t redeem the rewards. I used to hear stats that 75% of air miles were never redeemed.

    The rewards game is just a gimmick. We’d much rather (and do) pay for the item once, and be done. No statements, no reconciling, no redeeming.

    There is no rewards program that is worth allowing those snakes into my life. Life is much simpler without them.

  3. Thanks for sharing this article, Pete. Excellent write up and summary of the issue.

  4. Mrs. Micah says

    I thought about this when applying recently. It seemed like my choices were no annual fee or fee but rewards. Since we’re not planning to use the card for most of our spending at this point (I want to get the hang of using it and then paying it off!), I doubt we’d get that much back in rewards. If we do, it’ll definitely be cash. I can’t think of anything else that I KNOW I can use all the time.

  5. MyMoneyAdventure says

    I just was about to write the same type of post! I recently decided to cancel my rewards credit card because it was not worth the hassle. I’m trying to simplify my finances, not increase them.

  6. I have an Amex Blue card that earns rewards points. I’ve redeemed my points a number of times. The way I see it, I don’t go out of my way to make a charge. I would use the card anyway most times. The rewards are just a bonus. Plus we make sure to pay off our balance every month.

    You have to read the fine print and see if a rewards card will be worth it for you.

  7. I actually use my card for nearly all my purchases, including some bills. This gives me cash back of about $35-40/month, which I deposit directly into my Roth IRA. This adds up quickly.

    But you are right, it really takes a disciplined spender to make credit card rewards work for you.